Are your AI conversations actually private...or just perceived that way?
Did you know that private conversations you’re having with tools like ChatGPT or Claude might
not be private at all?
Hey, do we even understand what privacy means now in the age of AI? And more importantly,
do your employees understand it?
I came across a recent case that stopped me in my tracks. It involves AI, fraud, and attorney
client privilege, and it highlights something every leader needs to be thinking about right now.
If you want to dig into the case yourself: United States of America v. Bradley Heppner
The moment AI stopped being “just a tool”
Here’s the situation. An individual facing fraud charges used an AI tool to help prepare a legal defense. That’s something many of us would do. You put information in, you try to get clarity, you try to think through your options. But here’s where it shifts.
The information entered into the AI system was later accessed and used as part of the case. The defense argued attorney client privilege. The court said no. Why? Because interacting with AI did not meet the standards for legal confidentiality.
Anything typed into these tools may not carry the protections people assume. Just like the phrase we’ve all heard, anything you say can and will be used against you. That logic is starting to apply to what you type into AI.
3 Leadership Wake-Up Calls About AI and Privacy
1. Perceived privacy is not legal privacy
Leaders have to wake up to this alarm signal. We’ve created a work culture where AI feels like a private assistant. It feels like a one-on-one conversation. But it’s not. Perceived privacy is not the same as legal privacy.
When people interact with AI, they often assume:
- This is confidential.
- This is temporary.
- This is “just between me and the tool.”
That assumption is now risky. From a leadership standpoint, this is no longer about technology literacy.
It’s about behavioral clarity.
If your team doesn’t understand the difference between feeling private and being protected, they will unintentionally expose information.
2. Your employees are already crossing the line
Truth be told employees are using AI right now. They are pasting in:
- Internal documents
- Strategy questions
- Sensitive client scenarios
- Early-stage ideas
And they’re doing it for the right reasons: speed, clarity, and better work. That’s not the issue.
The issue is they may not understand where the boundary is.
When tools feel conversational and safe, people naturally share more than they should. Not because they’re careless, but because the environment feels low-risk.
That’s a leadership blind spot.
3. Digital conversations are not automatically protected
This case reinforces something leaders need to say out loud:
- AI tools are not inherently confidential.
- Internal chats at work are not guaranteed to be private.
- Digital conversations may not be legally protected.
That includes tools like:
- AI assistants
- Workplace chat platforms
- Integrated copilots
If your team assumes these spaces function like private conversations, you’ve got a gap. And gaps like this don’t show up until something goes wrong.
Where this becomes a leadership problem
Picture this:
A mid-level manager is trying to solve a client issue. They paste details into an AI tool to get a better answer. They include specifics to improve the output.
They’re moving fast. They’re trying to do good work.
But now that information is exposed in a way they didn’t anticipate.
That’s not a technology failure. That’s a leadership clarity failure.
What leaders should do now
In the age of AI, leadership has to move from awareness to action.
Three practical shifts:
- Define what “private” actually means in your organization
Don’t assume people know. Spelll it out in plain language. - Create AI guidelines based on real scenarios
Skip the long policy documents that sit on a shelf. Show your team what safe and unsafe usage actually looks like in their day-to-day work. - Train judgment, not just compliance
You goal is not to restrict AI use. You need your people to think before they type.
Because in this environment, awareness drives trust. And trust protects the organization.
AI is a powerful tool. But it’s also reshaping the invisible rules around information, trust, and responsibility we’ve relied on for years. The leaders who get ahead of this won’t just adopt AI faster. They’ll build organizations where people know how to use it wisely. And that’s the difference between automation that accelerates your business and automation that quietly exposes it.


